Comparing Mesh Types
You have already examined the velocity plot and seen that the numerical solution compares well with the experimental data. Compare the velocity data that is produced on this mesh with that produced on the Hexahedral Mesh and the Tetrahedral Mesh.
First, import the data from the previous two simulations:
- Open the node.
- Right-click the node and select .
- Select file hex380.csv and click Open.
- Do the same to import the data saved in file tet380.csv.
To plot the imported data:
- Open the node.
- Right-click the Data Series node and select .
- In the Add Data Providers to Plot dialog, select hex380 and click OK.
-
Expand the
node and set the following properties:
Node Property Value hex380 Legend Name HexMesh Sort Plot Data Activated Line Style
Style Solid Symbol Style
Shape None - Once again, right-click the Data Series node and select .
- In the Add Data Providers to Plot dialog, select tet380 and click OK.
-
Select the
node and set the following properties:
Node Property Value tet380 Legend Name TetMesh Sort Plot Data Activated Line Style
Style Solid Symbol Style
Shape None -
Expand the
node and set the following properties:
Node Property Value exp380 Legend Name Experimental Symbol Style
Color Black -
Expand the
node and set the following properties:
Node Property Value X=0.38 Legend Name PolyMesh Sort Plot Data Activated Line Style
Style Solid Symbol Style
Shape None
The plot appears as shown below.
There is little difference in the quality of the results from the three meshes, although the result from the polyhedral mesh is slightly better than the other two in the recirculation zone. The polyhedral mesh has only 60,838 cells. The hexahedral mesh has 67,699 cells and the tetrahedral mesh has 140,141 cells. The analysis on the polyhedral mesh only required 121 iterations to reach convergence which compares to 221 for the hexahedral mesh and 181 for the tetrahedral mesh. The results therefore demonstrate the ability of polyhedral meshes to produce good quality results with lower cell counts and shorter run times than other mesh types.
- Save the simulation.